“Excellent…a valentine to the original Rod Serling series…a great premise…an ending that will warm the heart of any longtime fan of thoughtful science fiction, but also make you feel like a kid again; longing for just one more new episode of your favorite far-out show.”
-Den of Geek
“Extremely clever…boy, what a twist…I felt a childlike rush of emotion: What is the Twilight Zone? When do we get there?”
-Decider
“You do not want to be spoiled on the first scene, a superb fake-out that’s also the single most delightful moment this season has produced… a particularly clever episode of The Twilight Zone — a kind of riff on classic Twilight Zone themes as filtered through Adaptation… it feels a lot like a classic Twilight Zone episode.”
-Vulture
“Best for last… a helluva lot of fun to watch… playful and genuinely mysterious… also legitimately funny… keeps viewers on their toes… while still striking a decidedly fun tone.”
-BirthMoviesDeath
Reviews for "Try, Try"
“An inspired take on time loops… one of the reboot’s best episodes… a brilliantly thought-provoking and well-acted installment of The Twilight Zone which stands out as one of the reboot’s finest.”
-Screen Rant
"A-"
-The A.V. Club